CrownGrading Pro
Ready to grade your cards? Submit Cards →

Recurring Nightmare Card Details

Card Image Tap to enlarge
Recurring Nightmare
Magic: The Gathering Exodus - Illustrator Auto  ·  1998  ·  #72
8 Crown Grade
Near Mint
Cert # 000047376
Subgrades
8.5 Centering
8.5 Corners
7 Edges
7.5 Surface
Centering65/35 or better on the front. 80/20 or better on the back.
CornersClean and sharp corners with almost no visible wear. Tiny imperfections such as minuscule nicks & softening are present under magnification.
EdgesClean edges with minimal wear. Minor imperfections such as nicks & light chipping are visible by the naked eye and under magnification.
SurfaceVery clean surface with only the slightest signs of wear. Light scratches, tiny marks, & print lines are visible under close inspection.
✍️ Autograph Authentication Crown Verified
This Recurring Nightmare card carries a black ink autograph from artist Jeff Laubenstein, signed across the lower text box in a loose, flowing hand with a bold pink-red outline tracing the edges of the black lines. Crown Grading compared the signature with known examples of Laubenstein's signature and examined the card in hand, confirming the ink is live and not printed or copied. Crown Grading authenticates this autograph and stands behind it as genuine.
View full authentication report
Card Notes
Exodus arrived in 1998 as Magic's ninth expansion, representing a pivotal moment when the game's mechanics and design philosophy matured considerably. The set introduced players to innovative mechanics and memorable cards that shaped competitive play for years. Exodus stands out in collector memory as a set that balanced powerful effects with beautiful, evocative artwork that defined late-'90s Magic aesthetics. Recurring Nightmare exemplifies why Exodus endures in player collections. The card presents a haunting illustration of spectral horror, capturing the supernatural dread central to Magic's black mana philosophy. Its mechanical elegance and artistic presentation made it instantly iconic, drawing collectors who appreciate cards where gameplay innovation and visual storytelling converge perfectly.
Market Value
$53.00 Grade 8-8.5 value
Source: PriceCharting · Updated Nov 08, 2026
Market Reference
Raw / Ungraded
$68.00
Grade 8-8.5
$53.00
Value by Grade · PriceCharting
Price History — This Grade
Price data from PriceCharting
Population Insights
1 Total Pop
1 This Grade
0 Higher Grade
0 Lower Grade
Grade Count
8 THIS SLAB 1
★  Subgrade Ranking
Ranks #1 of 1 among Grade 8 copies
Subgrade Profile — Centering / Corners / Edges / Surface
8.5 / 8.5 / 7 / 7.5
0 Better
1 Equal
0 Lower
Think your card can grade higher?

Cards like this average a 8.0 with Crown — yours graded 8.00

Submit Your Card →
Free submission packet

Want your own cards graded?

What you get back, current per-card pricing, and a shipping checklist — in your inbox in seconds. No account needed.