CrownGrading Pro
Ready to grade your cards? Submit Cards →

Don Mattingly Card Details

Card Image Tap to enlarge
Don Mattingly
Fleer  ·  1985  ·  #133
8.5 Crown Grade
Near Mint+
Cert # 000053023
Subgrades
7.5 Centering
9 Corners
8.5 Edges
9 Surface
Centering80/20 or better on the front. 85/15 or better on the back.
CornersCorners are mostly sharp with very slight wear at the tips. Imperfections are barely noticeable without magnification.
EdgesEdges have almost no signs of fraying, chipping, and nicks. Under magnification, multiple flaws are visible, but not significant.
SurfaceNear-perfect surface with only the tiniest imperfections visible under close inspection. Surface appears clean and free of noticeable marks.
Card Notes
The 1985 Fleer set marked a significant moment in trading card history as one of the first major challenges to Topps' long-standing monopoly. Fleer's bold design aesthetic and glossy finish offered collectors a fresh alternative, and the set's success helped reshape the modern card market. This release is remembered as a watershed moment that energized the hobby and proved there was room for competition and innovation in the space. Don Mattingly's 1985 Fleer rookie card captures him as a promising young talent on the cusp of stardom. Collectors have long sought this card as both an iconic rookie issue and a touchstone of 1980s baseball cards. Mattingly would go on to become a Yankees legend, making his early cards like this one particularly prized by fans of the team and serious vintage collectors alike.
Market Value
Price data not yet available — check back soon.
Price data from PriceCharting
Population Insights
1 Total Pop
1 This Grade
0 Higher Grade
0 Lower Grade
Grade Count
8.5 THIS SLAB 1
★  Subgrade Ranking
Ranks #1 of 1 among Grade 8.5 copies
Subgrade Profile — Centering / Corners / Edges / Surface
7.5 / 9 / 8.5 / 9
0 Better
1 Equal
0 Lower
Think your card can grade higher?

Cards like this average a 8.5 with Crown — yours graded 8.50

Submit Your Card →
Free submission packet

Want your own cards graded?

What you get back, current per-card pricing, and a shipping checklist — in your inbox in seconds. No account needed.